Idolator’s American Idolatry: The Sundance Kid Lives To See Another Day

Feb 23rd, 2007 // 10 Comments

Welcome to Idolator’s American Idolatry, where we look at the pop-cultural steamroller that is American Idol. Last night’s episode featured the first four eliminations, including the dismissal of Rudy Cardenas (above) and the survival of the increasingly loathesome Sundance Head; it also featured a performance by season-three winner Fantasia, which was introduced by an extremely awkward segment in which Ryan Seacrest cut Quincy Jones off as he was trying to explain how The Color Purple, which will star Fantasia come April, is actually about the color purple. We’re sure that, had Seacrest allowed Quincy to finish his sentence, the explanation would have made sense, but as we’re learning more and more with each episode, there isn’t all that much room for logic in the Idol universe.

WHO’S (INEXPLICABLY) IN): Sundance, Alaina, and Antonella. Seriously, are we going to have to put up with this Vote For The Worst crap for much longer? Sundance is going to bust a vein on stage the next time he’s inspired to overemote in public.

WHO’S OUT: Paul the falsetto-challenged; Amy the bland; Nicole the screechy; Rudy the undaunted. All performed their requisite swan songs; Nicole looked like she was going to lose it on stage more than anyone else. (Perhaps she needed that “overrehearsing.”)

BUT REMEMBER, SOMETIMES NOT WINNING IS EVEN BETTER THAN WINNING: This year’s goodbye-montage song is the Nickelbackian Chris Daughtry track “Home,” a genius bit of keep-it-in-the-family placement that ensures the Idol runner-up’s place in the Billboard top 10 until at least June.

WE THOUGHT “BROADWAY” WAS A BAD WAY TO SOUND: But everyone seemed pretty excited for Fantasia’s announcement that she was going to star in The Color Purple come April. What’s next–Ruben Studdard announcing a run of cabaret shows?

THIS YEAR, ALL THE CONTESTANTS WILL GET NOT ONE, BUT TWO LESSONS IN BUILDING THEIR OWN CLOTHING LINE: Celebrity guests for this season were announced last night, and they include brand-building pop stars Gwen Stefani and Jennifer Lopez. We’re a little sad that they won’t be put through the judgment-night segment of the Idol process; after all, one would think that the reedy-voiced J. Lo needs the gentle “it’s a singing competition” reminder even more than some of the outsized-personality hopefuls from the show’s early weeks.

American Idol []
Earlier: Idolator’s American Idolatry archives


  1. chrisb

    I can’t watch the results shows. Those group numbers are too painful. They’re like bad high school musical productions.

    So my thanks, Idolators, for keeping me posted.

  2. Maura Johnston

    Oh god, I couldn’t even bring myself to recap that part. “Sowing The Seeds Of Love” is one of my favorite songs of all time, and hearing Sundance Head sing a verse…

  3. Hallux Valgus

    Best part of the evening:
    Rudy: “If it’s alright with you, I’m gonna go out with a bang!”
    (2 or 3 audience member respond with a whimper)

    oh- and no reference to Paula Abdul? That chick has Beermuffs- the more wasted she gets, the better everyone sounds. I think she told all 4 departees that they were one of the best vocalists on the show.

  4. Anonymous

    What about when Lakisha jumped the gun and approached the departing Nicole, only to realize she was indeed the only one other than Nicole in center stage. So she walked backwards, awkwardly.

    I get so much out of other people’s discomfort.

  5. JedTheMime

    That list of upcoming celeb apperances was the saddest thing ever. If they didn’t have a Paul McCartney or Michael Jackson to announce, why bother? I mean seriously, J.Lo? Gwen Stefani? I’m SO not looking forward to the group performance of “Don’t Speak”.

  6. Maura Johnston

    they should force sundance to dress up like one of the harajuku girls.

  7. Hamm Beerger

    Re: Putting up with VFTW. Yes, you will have to put up with them for a while. They take credit (I think deservedly) for Constantine Maroulis, Kevin Covais, and Kellie Pickler. All three of those charlatans kept people saying whathafuck? until at least the top 12.

  8. Maura Johnston

    Oh man, so that Village Voice cover story is pretty much their fault, too?! Okay, they are going DOWN.

  9. Rory B. Bellows

    I think Vote for the Worst gets too much credit. Kellie Pickler made it pretty far on her own last year. They only targeted her for a week or two.

    I think people under-estimate the power of sentimental favorites. Like the fact that Sunjay was in the top 4 last night.

  10. nicoel

    The crew at Defamer is donning “Team Sundance” shirts already.

Leave A Comment