No, Wait, <em>This</em> Is The Music Equivalent Of Fantasy Baseball

Aug 21st, 2007 // 9 Comments

mrmet.jpgThe folks at the LimeWire Blog have come up with a method for reviewing albums called “indie rock baseball,” in which you take a record and, starting off with two outs and no one on base, subsequently review said album based on how clutch it is–namely, if it can score a run before it strikes out with three skippable tracks. The rules follow:

* You start with two outs and no one on base.
* Each time you skip to the next track without finishing the one you were listening to, that’s a strike.
* Each time you finish a song, that’s a ball.
* Each time you actually *like* a song, that’s a hit. Naturally. Or a single, if you prefer. This also resets the count (as would four balls). Now you would have a runner on. Another hit (or walk) would advance the runner, etc.
* There are multi-base hits for songs you really like. It does help open things up, but please use sparingly, as we don’t want these things to end up being just another bunch of lopsided Yankee-Devil Ray games.
* A runner scores from 2nd on a hit. I guess this would also imply a runner on 1st would score on a double. Use your best judgment.
* Once a record reaches three strikes, it’s OUT. Of your CD player (or preferred music player).
* Otherwise, you post the result (e.g. 1 run, 2 left on base).

But why stop at indie rock? Sure, the Yo La Tengo-Mets connection has even been commemorated on a shirt, but anyone who’s been to a game at Shea knows that there’s a fine tradition of marrying freestyle with crucial moments in baseball. In honor of that fact, I just played this game with Freestyle’s Greatest Beats, Vol. 1; the “score” wound up being 4-0 (with runners stranded on first and third) thanks to the unfortunate sequencing of a Sa-Fire song right after Jellybean’s “The Mexican.” (Seriously, though, that comp is all gold otherwise.) And I’m sure that other genres can play along as well. So I’m just going to completely throw open the door to mass nerdiness here and invite you all to play along below:

Indie Rock Baseball [LimeWire Blog, via On The Beat]

  1. MikeF

    love it – - no one seems to like Rilo Kiley though :(

  2. raihala

    I thought part of liking music was that you didn’t have to know anything about sports(?)

  3. natepatrin

    I prefer a pitcher-biased system, which I guess means that the new UGK is Santana’s 17-K start and each leaked 50 Cent single is another Kyle Farnsworth flameout.

  4. Charlie Kerfelds Jetsons Tee

    I do what Pitchfork tells me to do!


  5. natepatrin

    @Charlie Kerfelds Jetsons Tee: In that case, pick up Brian Buscher for your fantasy team. Trust me on this.

  6. revmatty

    This is possibly the stupidest idea I’ve heard all week. Though it’s still better than most music review systems…

  7. Anonymous

    They have a site:

    The guys behind it are local Brooklyn rockers and nice peoples.

  8. cerulgalactus

    @MikeF: I do. It’s probably going to end up my second favourite album of the year, right behind the brilliance of Blue Scholars’ Bayani.

  9. Vince Neilstein

    Absolutely amazing! I wonder if Lastings Milledge’s rap would score any runs?

Leave A Comment