Creed’s Path Toward Critical Respectability Hits A Speed Bump

Oct 27th, 2009 // 12 Comments

Creed continued its promotional jaunt for its just-out album Full Circle today with a stop at Live With Regis And Kelly; the band performed its new single “Rain,” and, uh, well. Let’s just say that for a once-pummeled band that’s inching toward a full-on “hey, they weren’t that bad” critical reappraisal, frontman Scott Stapp sure did sound like he’d ingested some Magical Stay Out Of Tune With The Rest Of The Band beans right before going onstage. Clip after the jump.





I guess the guitars are kind of pretty, but… well, just for comparison’s sake, one of the “Creed Shreds” videos:



Which sounds better?


Creed – Rain (Live @ Regis and Kelly) [YouTube; HT Ned Raggett]
Creed Shreds! Funny Sounding Vocals! [YouTube]
Earlier: New York Times Spearheads Creed Rehabilitation Project / Slate Rethinks Creed

idolator

  1. Those “XX Shreds” videos are pure awesome. That guy is an evil genius.

  2. Dear Lord, that’s out of tune. I think it’s not just Scott. I think one of the guitars is out, too, but it doesn’t matter with acoustic because you just have to strum them a lot to make them MEAN SOMETHING SPECIAL. It’s what’s kept the Jason Mraz’s of the world going.

  3. Between Lisa Loeb, late-Liz Phair, and Natalie Imbruglia, I’m leaning towards Natalie Imbruglia inspiration for the lyrics (but I keep hearing Hillary Duff screaming “Let the RRAAAAIN fall down” in my head).

  4. At least the song is short.

  5. DJP

    all I keep thinking is “THEY TOOK OUR JOBS”

  6. give him a break. it’s pretty early in the morning, and it’s a long drive to NYC from the gainsville denny’s.

  7. DJP- That is EXACTLY what I hear as well.

  8. @Bernard: ahahaha best callback everrrrr

  9. Just as a data point, “Full Circle” is currently No. 1 on iTunes…

  10. Wait, one of them is better than the other? They’re both still Creed so I’d have to dispute that contention.

  11. LHS

    Um, he always sounds out of step with the band of smug, shallow jocks at the guitar mass. He just always goes for it way too hard from note one and blows his voice instantly, forgetting that there aren’t second takes, throat-coat, and studio tricks when you aren’t in a studio. Also, why does Scott Stapp remind me so much of Guy Fieri?

  12. Unless someone can promise me that Stapp threw in a “YASSEAH!!!”, I’m not watching that first clip.

Leave A Comment