Whatcha Say: The Good, The Bad And The ‘Idol’ In This Week’s Reader Comments

This week brought not only big shakeups at American Idol, but also new music from Jesse McCartney and Natalia Kills, a new video blog from David Archuleta and the first look at a scene from Mega Python Vs. Gatoroid—i.e. the upcoming B-movie starring Tiffany and Debbie Gibson. And just how did our readers respond to all this pop hustle? Read on!

Ellen Kara American Idol
:: Fred wanted answers on Has Kara DioGuardi Been Fired From American Idol?: “What’s the real reason that she was fired? I thought that she was an excellent judge. Actually, she was even better than Randy and Simon in my opinion. So, what really happened? Please let me know.”

:: Amy flattened us on Selena Gomez’s Birthday Cake Wrecks: “Are you kidding me!?!?!?!?!? Those cakes are awesome!!!!! I <3333 them!!! Seriously people?? Ur just jealous because these cake rock the icing off of urs!! Cake Boss deffinently! They look amazing! Jeez people!”

:: Dan Washuk beep-beep, beep-beep yeah’d on Jonas Brothers Cover The Beatles For Obama And Paul McCartney: “I thought the Jonas Brothers sounded surprisingly good, but then I realized that not only was Paul’s band backing them up but they were in on the vocals as well. Even I could sound good with that kind of backup..!!!”

:: Petey was pumped for Jesse McCartney Gets Buried Alive With Auto-Tune On Step Up 3-D Track “Up”: “im sorryy but i actually kinda like it. maybe its cause i love jesse and he is my husband but im still completely unbiased lol its an ok song.”

:: Alex reflected on Hear The Longer Version Of Natalia Kills’ Latest Song “Mirrors”: “This song is so amazing! Even better than her promotional singles (way better actually), which I wasn’t sure if that was going to happen or not. I cannot wait for her album! It’s gonna be epic. :)”

:: Lyrix was feeling calm and collected on David Archuleta Looks Playfully Peaceful On “Something ‘Bout Love” Video Shoot: “‘Playfully Peaceful’ That’s a wonderful way to describe David Archuleta. And, it does fit him to a T.”

:: Kitty, however, wasn’t feeling the peace, love and harmony: “he is so NOT CUTE SORRYYYYYYYYY :):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):)::):):):):):):):):))”

:: Meanwhile, LaLiliana offered some reassurance on David Archuleta: “Sometimes I Think People Have Forgotten About Me”: “If David thinks we could forget him, he is so wrong. So very wrong. He is a whole lotta love to just take lightly. Oh no. We will be seeing David perform live. He is an experience not to be missed.”

:: COMMENT OF THE WEEK — The zinger of the past seven days comes from Teenage Dream, who got downright dirrty on Deborah Gibson and Tiffany Battle (In Short Dresses) In Mega Python Vs. Gatoroid: “Can’t wait until XTina signs on to play their mother in the sequel!”