Sadly, there was no Kelly or Carrie at the event, but Season 9′s “Sanjaya” Tim Urban showed up! (The actual Sanjaya was not. We’re sure he was very busy doing… seriously, why wasn’t he there?)
And if you’re wondering where LA-based Adam Lambert and David Cook were, THR explains: “The latter had non-cancellable meetings apparently. The former? We’re not sure, but needless to say, we were beyond bummed that he couldn’t join our ridiculously fun shoot.”
Check out Allison Iraheta, Blake Lewis, David Archuleta, Kimberly Caldwell, Kris Allen, Elliott Yamin and more hang out in the behind-the-scenes footage and interviews below.
Check out THR‘s Where Are They Now to find out what all these Idols have been up to since their time on the show. (One alum is a Warbler on Glee! Ah, the lucky man who gets to two-step right behind Darren Criss.)