Whatcha Say: The Good, The Bad And The ‘Idol’ In This Week’s Reader Comments

Robbie Daw | July 30, 2010 5:00 pm

This week brought not only big shakeups at American Idol, but also new music from Jesse McCartney and Natalia Kills, a new video blog from David Archuleta and the first look at a scene from Mega Python Vs. Gatoroid—i.e. the upcoming B-movie starring Tiffany and Debbie Gibson. And just how did our readers respond to all this pop hustle? Read on!

:: Fred wanted answers on Has Kara DioGuardi Been Fired From American Idol?: “What’s the real reason that she was fired? I thought that she was an excellent judge. Actually, she was even better than Randy and Simon in my opinion. So, what really happened? Please let me know.”

:: Amy flattened us on Selena Gomez’s Birthday Cake Wrecks: “Are you kidding me!?!?!?!?!? Those cakes are awesome!!!!! I <3333 them!!! Seriously people?? Ur just jealous because these cake rock the icing off of urs!! Cake Boss deffinently! They look amazing! Jeez people!”

:: Dan Washuk beep-beep, beep-beep yeah’d on Jonas Brothers Cover The Beatles For Obama And Paul McCartney: “I thought the Jonas Brothers sounded surprisingly good, but then I realized that not only was Paul’s band backing them up but they were in on the vocals as well. Even I could sound good with that kind of backup..!!!”

:: Petey was pumped for Jesse McCartney Gets Buried Alive With Auto-Tune On Step Up 3-D Track “Up”: “im sorryy but i actually kinda like it. maybe its cause i love jesse and he is my husband but im still completely unbiased lol its an ok song.”

:: Alex reflected on Hear The Longer Version Of Natalia Kills’ Latest Song “Mirrors”: “This song is so amazing! Even better than her promotional singles (way better actually), which I wasn’t sure if that was going to happen or not. I cannot wait for her album! It’s gonna be epic. :)”

:: Lyrix was feeling calm and collected on David Archuleta Looks Playfully Peaceful On “Something ‘Bout Love” Video Shoot: “‘Playfully Peaceful’ That’s a wonderful way to describe David Archuleta. And, it does fit him to a T.”

:: Kitty, however, wasn’t feeling the peace, love and harmony: “he is so NOT CUTE SORRYYYYYYYYY :):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):):)::):):):):):):):):))”

:: Meanwhile, LaLiliana offered some reassurance on David Archuleta: “Sometimes I Think People Have Forgotten About Me”: “If David thinks we could forget him, he is so wrong. So very wrong. He is a whole lotta love to just take lightly. Oh no. We will be seeing David perform live. He is an experience not to be missed.”

:: COMMENT OF THE WEEK — The zinger of the past seven days comes from Teenage Dream, who got downright dirrty on Deborah Gibson and Tiffany Battle (In Short Dresses) In Mega Python Vs. Gatoroid: “Can’t wait until XTina signs on to play their mother in the sequel!”