Whatcha Say: The Good, The Bad & The Toscano In This Week’s Reader Comments

Robbie Daw | April 8, 2011 5:30 pm

Kelly Rowland was motivated to get her freak on with Lil Wayne! Pia Toscano was voted off American Idol? A brand new Britney Spears music video!! Our readers had plenty to mull over as they navigated their way across the bouncy terrain of Planet Pop this week. See what they had to say below! :: M brought the fire and brimstone to Kelly Rowland And Lil Wayne Steam Up Their “Motivation” Video: “I’m sorry…this video screams bisexuality…from the purple triangular outfit to the Jessica White hand all over Kelly part…I am done with this Satanic agenda for the LGBT community. Don’t buy into it people and definitely don’t support it!”

Kelly Rowland Motivation video
:: Mee countered with the following: “M, go somewhere else. This is not a place for religious banter. You clearly know your bible, so you probably don’t eat shellfish, or wear polyester and any other fabric blend. Because you cannot truly be religious, if your damnation is only on the things you don’t like, and the writings you don’t like, you just ignore. Bisexuality and homosexuality are things found in many animal species in the world, therefor either ‘god’ made a mistake, thereby questioning his ‘omnipotence’ and making him not the ‘all-powerful, all-knowing god” he is, or the bible is not true… if you really need a book to tell you what’s good and what’s not, I’m really sorry for you.”

:: Tahoegeminii was turned off by Mariah Carey Bares Her Baby Bod For Life & Style: “…no one has wanted to see Mariah’s body for a good 3 years since she turned into an old blimp that continued to sausage herself into porno prom dresses and prance around like she is 3…”

:: Brandon Hall approved of Britney Spears Goes Underground In her “Till The World Ends” Video: “This is such an improvement over her Hold It Against Me video, in fact Id say this is probably her best video since 2004… Move over Beyonce, who knew Britney was so Bootylicious?”

:: Justin M. simply called for a cease-fire: “So great. Go Britney! What a fun music video . . . I loved the ending! Why don’t people stop comparing Britney to Gaga? They are so completely different and are at completely different points in their careers!”

:: Aaron Howard was equally as impressed with Brit’s latest on Review Revue: Critics React To Britney Spears’ “Till The World Ends” Video: “The video is amazing in my book compared to ‘Hold it against me.’ I agree with most of the critics above. Britney may not be able to dance like she used to, but this video is edited just right to make us believe like she does and it just flashes me back to the good old days of ‘Toxic’ and ‘Oops…I Did it Again’.”

:: John seemed to be asking for Roman’s revenge on Equal Opportunity Lap Dancer Nicki Minaj Gives Female Fan A Show In Orlando: “That picture does Nicki no favors. She kind of looks like Bert from Sesame Street done up in drag!”

:: Brimeon delivered a verdict on You Be The Judge: Porcelain Black’s “This Is What Rock N Roll Looks Like”: “Her older music is HOT. And Idolator, please follow her. She’s a much needed commodity in the pop world.”

:: Alex was shocked by the outcome on American Idol: Frontrunner Pia Toscano Voted Off: “That’s messed up. Shows America’s audiences don’t know what they really want or what a true singer is from mediocrity.”

:: Pamela didn’t seem to mind, though: “It takes more than flawless vocals to make up the entire package! Pia’s weakness was her stage presence … or lack of it. She was so uncomfortable taking command of the stage and it showed. If you’re going to a concert, don’t you want someone to draw you in? An entertainer has it all – vocals, looks, personality, likeability … and an ever captivating presence on the stage.”