Whatcha Say: The Good, The Bad & The Haley In This Week’s Reader Comments

Robbie Daw | June 3, 2011 5:30 pm

Over the past week, Kelly Clarkson teased music fans with five seconds of a new song, Rihanna shocked with a violent video, Lady Gaga’s Born This Way bulldozed its way to #1 on the album chart, Beyonce’s new tell-off jam premiered and there was much ado about American Idol Season 10 favorite Haley Reinhart. Head below to see how our readers reacted to all of this pop drama!

Kelly Clarkson
:: John can’t hardly wait for July after reading Listen To 5 Seconds Of Kelly Clarkson’s New Song “Let Me Down”: “With all of this great music, what’s the holdup? They waiting for Amazon to sell it for 98 cents?”

:: Chris was equally energized by the short snippet: “RELEASE NOWW!!!! Please RCA!! you can’t torment us with this wait!! has to be lead single! Summer smash hit!!!”

:: Ditto with Sassy: “I cannot stand the wait. We need new Kelly soon!!! I am so tired of what is on the radio. I miss this brilliant voice so much!!!!!!!! Come on July and September!!!”

:: AH objected to Rihanna’s Violent “Man Down” Video Blasted By Parents Television Council: “A lot of movies and TV shows depict murders…aired on television. There is footage of war and crime and shootouts on CNN…aired on television. What makes this music video any different? It’s almost a form of entertainment to some people. Personally, I think ‘parents’ should be more concerned about children and teens playing extremely violent, realistic video games than a music video.”

:: Redshoes4all did a happy dance on Haley Reinhart Sits Down With Regis And Kelly, Sings “House Of The Rising Sun”: “Love HALEY!! She was the Best Entertainer and BEST Preformer of the Season!!! Sold more ITUNES and had more Utube hits than ANY of the ‘others’! Can’t wait to see what the FUTURE brings!! Best of LUCK Haley!!”

:: HEP was also stanning for Haley: “IN MY BOOK HALEY YOUR ARE THE AMERICAN IDOL WINNER OF SEASON 10,TRULY THE BEST VOICE ON THAT SHOW THIS YEAR,YOUR “HOUSE OF THE RISING SUN” WAS THE MUSICAL HIGHLIGHT OF AMERICAN IDOL”

:: Meanwhile, tj expressed his disappointment on Haley Reinhart’s Original Song Got Booted Because Of Bono And Spider-Man: “Idol has no respect for Haley and what she did for the show this season. The best thing for Haley would be to get the hell as far away from Idol now as possible. Cut her own deals and move on. Idol had their chance and didn’t take it. That’s their loss! Haley will do just fine without them and won’t have to deal with their dishonest and disrespectful treatment of her. Good riddance Idol and welcome to the dance, Haley!”

:: Mel, on the other hand, was a-okay with how things turned out: “Nope, I would have rather seen Bono.”

:: bluva4life defended their favorite diva on Review Revue: Critics React To Beyonce’s “Best Thing I Never Had”: “lol if its not top 10 its not good enough for them lmao! i can’t say “you” because “you” cannot create music. However the average musician cannot even TOUCH beyonce. And again, she will sale MILLIONS in the end. She WILL be top 5 on forbes. Will see who’s the real flop.”

:: Nyan didn’t think Mother Monster played fair after reading Lady Gaga’s Born This Way Tops Chart With 1.1 Million Copies Sold: “I love Lady Gaga and the album but to me, selling an album that you’ve worked really hard on for only 99 cents is a very cheap and sly way to sell over a million copies of an album. Britney did it without a trick like that, so Gaga can. I love her and her music, but I would be a little ashamed.”